NS-006
observedwrong-object-correct-shape
Scraping the largest asset returns a recommendation, not the subject
- reads as
- A parser extracts an image from the page and it is a valid, plausible image. Conclusion drawn: extraction succeeded.
- actually
- The page embeds related items alongside the subject. Ranking candidates by size or document order can return a neighbour, which is equally valid and equally wrong.
- blind because
- Both results are real images from the correct domain. Nothing about the artifact reveals it is the wrong one.
- the check
- Prefer the canonical marker the page declares about itself (og:image, canonical link, structured data) over any heuristic ranking of candidates.
- cost of missing
- Silent substitution. Detected only when two different inputs return the same output.
- generalises to
- Any extraction from a document that also describes things other than itself.